Renewable Energy Generation Facility (REGF) and Battery Energy Storage Systems (BESS) Provisions
The City of Ottawa is proposing to establish official plan and zoning provisions for renewable energy generation and battery energy storage uses in accordance with new Official Plan policy.
The City of Ottawa is proposing to establish official plan and zoning provisions for renewable energy generation and battery energy storage uses in accordance with new Official Plan policy.
-
Proposed Official Plan and Zoning By-law Amendments for Battery Energy Storage Systems (BESS)
Share Proposed Official Plan and Zoning By-law Amendments for Battery Energy Storage Systems (BESS) on Facebook Share Proposed Official Plan and Zoning By-law Amendments for Battery Energy Storage Systems (BESS) on Twitter Share Proposed Official Plan and Zoning By-law Amendments for Battery Energy Storage Systems (BESS) on Linkedin Email Proposed Official Plan and Zoning By-law Amendments for Battery Energy Storage Systems (BESS) linkBESS is an emerging technology using batteries and associated equipment to store excess energy from the electrical grid, which can then discharge energy in periods of high demand. They are used to provide backup power to individual sites as well as to support the provincial grid. Since phasing out natural gas fired power stations, the Ontario government has forecasted the need to expand the electricity grid to meet higher electrification of large energy consuming sectors, including transportation, manufacturing, water and building envelope heating. The additional capacity required has targeted renewable energy sources, including solar and wind as well as storage.
On May 9, 2024, the Independent Electricity Systems Operator (IESO) executed contracts with ten (10) proposed transmission scale BESS projects in the province, two (2) of which are to be located in Ottawa Rural Wards 5 and 21. Public meetings were held by the BESS proponents as directed by the IESO through their Long-Term 1 (LT1) Request for Proposals process.
Both battery energy storage system projects will be required to meet all municipal planning approvals and by-laws (zoning, noise, fire, building code, etc.) that are currently in place and which may be approved as part of an upcoming report this fall. Proposed Official Plan and Zoning By-law provisions are intended to outline specific requirements for BESS in the development approvals process.
Provisions are being developed in a manner that is consistent with the Official Plan and ensures locally sensitive opportunities for new REGF developments.
Public and Stakeholder Input
Public and stakeholder input is an important part of developing locally-sensitive zoning provisions. In meeting the directives of the Official Plan, public and stakeholder input is recorded and considered carefully. Staff encourage residents and key stakeholders to provide feedback and participate in this process. Every effort will be made to incorporate feedback and requests submitted into the upcoming amendments, to the extent possible within the framework of the Planning Act.
For more information or to comment on the upcoming report click here.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ) about BESS technology can be found here
-
Battery Energy Storage Systems (BESS) Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Share Battery Energy Storage Systems (BESS) Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ) on Facebook Share Battery Energy Storage Systems (BESS) Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ) on Twitter Share Battery Energy Storage Systems (BESS) Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ) on Linkedin Email Battery Energy Storage Systems (BESS) Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ) linkJanuary 14, 2025
In October 2023, the Independent Electricity Systems Operator (IESO) put out a call for proposals for new Battery Energy Storage Systems (BESS). Through this competitive procurement process, known as the Long-term 1 Request for Proposals (LT1 RFP), the province looked to procure year-round capacity from new build storage facilities larger than 1 MW. This represented the largest energy storage procurement ever in Canada.
A report was tabled at the November 30, 2023 Agricultural and Rural Affairs Committee on four proposed BESS projects within Ottawa, one of which project received Council support, known as a Municipal Support Resolution (MSR).
On May 9, 2024, the IESO announced that ten proposed BESS projects were selected, totaling 1,784 megawatts (MW) of energy storage, including two to be located in rural west Ottawa.
A report on proposed Official Plan and Zoning By-law Amendments will be tabled at upcoming Agricultural and Rural Affairs and Planning and Housing Committees on January 23 and February 5 respectively.
The following are frequently asked questions related to the procurement and BESS.
Battery Energy Storage Systems (BESS) – Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ’s)
What are Battery Energy Storage Systems (BESS)?
Battery Energy Storage Systems (BESS) are energy retention systems that store and then discharge electricity back into the electricity grid when supply is low or when energy is most expensive. Lithium-ion batteries, the same batteries that are used in cell phones and electric vehicles, are the dominant form of energy storage today because they hold a charge longer than other types of batteries, are less expensive, and have a smaller footprint. BESS systems have a range of applications including smaller residential systems, larger commercial systems and public utility and transmission-scale systems similar to those under the LT1 RFP. BESS are also being used to store energy supplied from rooftop or ground mounted solar systems.
Who is the Independent Electricity Systems Operator (IESO)?
Electricity is a commodity that all residents use. It follows a process of production, transmission, and then direct delivery to customers. The Independent Electricity Systems Operator (IESO) is the authority responsible to manage the flow of electricity across Ontario and ensure service reliability by monitoring and forecasting energy needs, and controlling when and how new production can be integrated.
Why does the IESO want to invest in BESS?
The IESO has identified new challenges in accessing reliable electricity supply, which are related to a number of factors including: increased demand from expanding electrification and business investment; pressures on supply from aging infrastructure with the retirement of the Pickering nuclear facility, the refurbishment at Bruce and Darlington facilities; and expiring electricity supply and capacity contracts that IESO has with privately owned energy retailers.
Without a mechanism for storage, the electricity produced must be used immediately or it will be wasted in times of oversupply during off hours and shortages during peak hours. BESS have been identified as an important type of energy infrastructure to address the issue of peak hour shortages, as well as providing access to energy closer to home. BESS can also support renewable energy generation by way of wind and solar facilities, where production is intermittent.
As a result, IESO has identified the need to increase energy supply and storage capacity significantly, starting in 2025 through the latter part of the decade. In October 2023, the IESO put out a call for proposals for transmission scale BESS facilities. Through this competitive procurement process, province procured almost 3,000 megawatts (MW) of year-round capacity that is to be from new build storage facilities larger than 1 MW. This represented the largest energy storage procurement ever in Canada.
What is a megawatt?
A Watt is the amount of energy (in Joules) that an electrical device (such as a light) is burning per second that it is running. One watt is equal to one joule per second. A megawatt (MW) is one million watts. One megawatt hour (MWh) is equal to 1,000 kilowatt-hours (kWh). The number of homes that can be powered by a MWh depends on the average electricity consumption of the homes. In Ontario, an average household uses approximately 9,500 kWh per year.
What is a Municipal Support Resolution?
Where a project is proposed in an area governed by a municipal government, the IESO requires proponents to obtain confirmation of municipal support through a Municipal Support Resolution (MSR) as part of the application process. An MSR is general in nature and does not preclude a project from having to meet municipal regulatory requirements or obtain any municipal development approvals or permits should they be selected by the IESO.
As part of the 2023 procurement, the successful proponents have up to 20 months to obtain the MSR. Projects that included an MSR with their application were eligible to receive four (4) additional Rated Criteria points, which gave them a better chance of being selected.
Are there proposed BESS projects in Ottawa?
Yes, there are two transmission scale BESS projects proposed in rural west Ottawa. One in West Carleton-March (Ward 5) and the other is in Rideau-Jock (Ward 21).
Are there land use impacts associated with BESS?
There are different types and sizes of BESS. BESS that are intended to support the transmission grid are typically made up of several rechargeable batteries placed in storage containers that range in size. These facilities are often installed outdoors near to existing electrical infrastructure such as a sub-station. Containers can range in size, being approximately 10 to 40 feet in length and approximately 8 feet in height and width. Smaller scale BESS are used to provide backup power to support both residential and non-residential buildings. They can be placed either indoors or outdoors close to the buildings they are designed to support.
Once constructed, BESS require only routine maintenance. They can be monitored remotely and therefore traffic and onsite parking are minimal. Site lighting at BESS facilities is also minimal, except for security purposes. The absence of employees also means there is no water or sewer requirements at BESS facilities. Noise generated by cooling fans may require mitigation through the use of sound barriers or landscaping.
Specifically for transmission scale BESS, reducing risk of fire is an important consideration. Lithium-ion batteries contain flammable electrolytes that, if overheated, can short circuit and catch fire, also known as “thermal runaway”. More information is available in the FAQ on Fire Safety for BESS.
Are BESS facilities permitted in Ottawa’s Official Plan?
The Official Plan permit utility facilities which are subject to the Environmental Assessment Act in all designations of the Official Plan. However, only the transmission components of a BESS facility (i.e., the transformer station(s), transmission line(s) may be subject to the Class Environmental Assessment for Minor Transmission Facilities. The battery storage units associated with a BESS facility are subject to Planning Act requirements. Therefore, specific land use policy guidance is required to support BESS in Ottawa. These policies will be tabled at the Agricultural and Rural Affairs and Planning and Housing Committees on January 23 and February 5 respectively.
How are BESS facilities zoned?
BESS facilities are a specific type of energy storage system that store energy using batteries. Considerations for zoning must consider their intended use, preferred location and size. The Zoning By-law therefore needs to distinguish between a BESS facility intended as a standalone use and which is connected directly to the electrical grid and a BESS that is accessory and supports principal residential and non-residential uses.
Specific use zoning provisions for BESS facilities will be tabled at the Agricultural and Rural Affairs and Planning and Housing Committees on January 23 and February 5 respectively.
-
Battery Energy Storage Systems (BESS) Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ’s) on Fire Safety
Share Battery Energy Storage Systems (BESS) Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ’s) on Fire Safety on Facebook Share Battery Energy Storage Systems (BESS) Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ’s) on Fire Safety on Twitter Share Battery Energy Storage Systems (BESS) Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ’s) on Fire Safety on Linkedin Email Battery Energy Storage Systems (BESS) Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ’s) on Fire Safety linkAre BESS facilities safe?
The BESS industry is undergoing rapid growth and development. Lithium-ion batteries, commonly used in mobile phones and electric cars, are currently the dominant storage technology for large scale BESS facilities. Concerns have been raised regarding the safety of BESS facilities because lithium-ion batteries contain flammable electrolytes that, if overheated, can short circuit and catch fire, also known as “thermal runaway”. This type of fire can be difficult to extinguish and BESS infrastructure costly to replace. Reducing risk of fire is therefore an important consideration for both municipalities and project developers. Technology is consistently being improved with safety features to address these concerns, including cooling systems and real time temperature monitoring.
Who sets the fire safety requirements for BESS?
From a BESS permitting and approval standpoint, the process outlined in Hydro One’s BESS Fire Protection Risk & Response Assessment Standard (FPRRAS) is comprehensive. The Standard was specifically developed to address BESS in proximity to Hydro One’s transmission facilities. All BESS proponents are required to provide a self-certification per Appendix-1 of the FPRRAS stating that they have carried out the assessments and that the facility poses no safety or outage risk or unmitigated hazard to Hydro One employees and Hydro One’s transmission system. This self-certification is to be submitted to Hydro One during the commissioning of BESS facility prior to connecting to the Hydro One owned transmission system.
The following are assessments are listed under Appendix 1:
Hazard Mitigation Analysis, including UL 9540 Listing, UL9540A Test Reports, Fault Condition Assessment
Fisk Risk Assessment, including Community Risk Assessment and Air/Gas Dispersion Study
Fire Protection Design Documentation, Including Passive Fire Protection Systems and Active Fire Protection Systems
Commissioning Plan
Decommissioning Plan
Emergency Response Plan including Fire Department Training.
How do third party standards apply to the BESS projects in Ottawa?
The primary authority for the Installation and Approval of Energy Storage Systems connected to the electrical grid in Ontario is the Electrical Safety Authority (ESA). The ESA administers Part VIII of the Electricity Act and oversees the Ontario Electrical Safety Code (OESC). Inspections under the OSC would be ongoing during construction with the final inspection completed prior to energization. The electrical permitting process does not include specific BESS requirements.
NFPA 855
The National Fire Protection Association is an international non-profit organization that promotes safety standards, education, and training on fire and electrical-related hazards. NFPA 855 is the Standard for the Installation of Stationary Energy Storage Systems, which serves as a guideline for Canadian fire departments. The standard outlines processes for training, pre-incident planning, hazard mitigation analysis, testing, decommissioning, and post-incident handover procedures to energy storage system owner. Conditions set in NFPA 855 are required according to the Hydro One Standard - Section 5.0 Minimum Design Documentation, specifically in the Hazard Mitigation Analysis (which includes the Fault Condition Assessment). However, mandatory permitting and inspections are set by Hydro One Standard (not NFPA 855).
UL9540
UL 9540 is the North American safety standard for energy storage systems, which was developed by Underwriters Laboratories (UL). Both the American National Standards Institute (ANSI) and the Standards Council of Canada (SCC) have approved UL 9540. OESC mandates UL 9540 certification, so this would be regulated in the electrical safety code. Hydro One Standard also requires proof of compliance with UL 9540.
UL9540A
UL 9540A is a method for evaluating “thermal runaway” and sets out requirements for battery management systems (BMS) including battery safety, performance and communications protocols. This standard was developed to verify the effectiveness of protection levels against thermal runaway and fire hazards. The OESC mandates UL 9540A certification so this would be regulated in the electrical safety code. The Hydro One Standard also requires proof of compliance with UL 9540A.
How will Ottawa Fire Services respond to a fire incident involving a BESS system?
Ottawa Fire Services (OFS) develops emergency response plans based upon the occupancy and hazards specific to each location, creating standardized response protocols that address these needs. Prevention through early detection and suppression mitigation is our primary response. In the rare event of a fire emergency, OFS’ tactical priorities are focused on addressing any threat to life, reducing property loss, and mitigating environmental impacts. Fire suppression efforts will centre on preventing the spread of fire, with specialized air monitoring conducted throughout the event.
Is water to be used to respond to a fire incident involving a BESS system?
Automated prevention and suppression systems aim to mitigate the potential for a fire. In the event of a fire, fire tactics will primarily focus on protecting exposures to prevent the spread of flames. Each site will be assessed on a case-by-case basis to determine the appropriate water supply requirements, which may include municipal water supply, on-site storage reservoirs, or the installation of dry or remote hydrant systems.
Is there a risk of groundwater contamination due to run off if water is used to respond to a BESS fire?
The risk of groundwater contamination from firefighting water runoff during a BESS fire is estimated to be minimal. Most contaminants will burn off, with safety monitored throughout the event, and appropriate actions taken to protect the public if necessary. As with similar incidents involving the risk of contaminated liquids reaching the soil, the situation will be evaluated, and a cleanup service will be secured if needed. These considerations will also be factored into the site plan approval process, with a focus on prevention and mitigation strategies to further minimize environmental risks.
Will residents be able to be informed of the details related to a fire incident associated with a BESS, such as whether there was a risk of air or groundwater contamination?
OFS will have specialized teams conducting air monitoring throughout the event. If there is a risk of air contamination, it will be assessed and communicated during the incident, with updates provided as needed. Typically, the risk of air contamination is mitigated shortly after the fire is extinguished. Ongoing air monitoring and groundwater testing will be included as a condition of the approval process to ensure comprehensive environmental protection after the event.
Will Ottawa Fire Services inspect and certify that BESS projects are safe before they operational?
OFS plays a role in ensuring the safety of BESS projects. While the certification of the BESS unit itself is managed by external experts to ensure compliance with standards like NFPA 855, OFS’ focus is providing specialized expertise in firefighting capabilities, hazard mitigation and emergency response. OFS participates in the overall design review, which includes evaluating site access, layout, firefighting requirements, and the emergency response plan.
-
Official Plan and Zoning By-law Provisions for Renewable Energy Generation Facilities (REGF)
Share Official Plan and Zoning By-law Provisions for Renewable Energy Generation Facilities (REGF) on Facebook Share Official Plan and Zoning By-law Provisions for Renewable Energy Generation Facilities (REGF) on Twitter Share Official Plan and Zoning By-law Provisions for Renewable Energy Generation Facilities (REGF) on Linkedin Email Official Plan and Zoning By-law Provisions for Renewable Energy Generation Facilities (REGF) linkProvincial Authority to Approve REGF
The repeal of the Green Energy Act in 2019 restored municipal authority to regulate renewable energy generation land uses in Ontario, offering a new opportunity for municipal input on the siting of such infrastructure.
The Ontario Planning Act sets the rules for establishing municipal zoning by-laws, permitting municipalities to regulate the location of any energy generation and storage uses that are not undertaken by a Transmitter (Hydro One Corporation) or Ontario Power Generation, which are exempt from zoning under Section 62(1). The exemption does not apply to natural gas power plants where they are run by independent operators, providing limited opportunity for additional zoning provisions beyond the renewable sector.
The majority of REGF projects in Ontario are carried out by private enterprises or as joint projects with OPG or Hydro One Corporation, meaning that the majority will be subject to municipal zoning regulations.
There are certain classes of REGF projects which must obtain a Renewable Energy Approval (REA) from the Ministry of Environment, Conservation and Parks per Part V.0.1 of the Environmental Protection Act and O. Reg. 359/09. Provincial approval submission requirements vary depending on the project, however in all cases the applicant must provide evidence of both compliance with municipal policies and local public consultation. REA required public consultation is independent of any consultation that may be required by the municipality.
Zoning Intent
It is not the City’s intent to duplicate the provincial approvals process for renewable energy generation infrastructure. Rather the focus of the zoning by-law is to build upon existing provincial review processes to address local land use compatibility concerns and direct such development to the most appropriate locations within the parameters directed by the Official Plan.
Energy generation and storage infrastructure is not something that has previously been regulated by municipalities and requires thoughtful consideration of potential impacts from local considerations of potential land use conflicts, to the energy, resiliency, and climate impacts that may be associated with limiting opportunities for new energy generation projects.
The City will not be conducting, evaluating or commenting on independent health and safety research with respect to renewable energy generation and storage infrastructure. Staff will be looking to the expertise and direction provided by the Ministry of Public Health, Ministry of Environment, and the Ministry of Energy in incorporating health, safety, and environmental considerations that may be associated with renewable energy generation and storage infrastructure into zoning and/or other potential municipal review processes such as Site Plan Control.
Official Plan
Section 4.11 of the Official Plan provides guidance on where large-scale renewable energy facilities that are subject to a provincial procurement and approvals processes may be permitted. The OP also provides direction for where ‘subordinate’ renewable energy generation infrastructure that is not subject to provincial approvals, due to limited energy generation potential, may be permitted. Note that small-scale accessory use energy generation infrastructure, such as rooftop solar panels or a residential geothermal installation, is currently and will continue to be permitted in the zoning by-law everywhere that it functions to aid and contribute to the principal use of land.
As a principal use of land, the Official Plan permits renewable energy generation facilities in the following designations:
• Rural Countryside (see Schedule B9)
• Greenbelt Rural and Greenbelt Facility (see Schedule B9)
• Natural Environment Area - Greenspace sub-designation (see Schedules C11-A, C11-B and C11-C)
As a subordinate use of land (ancillary to a principal use), the Official Plan also permits renewable energy generation facilities in the following designations:
• Agricultural Resource Area (see Schedule B9)
• Rural Industrial and Logistics (see Schedule B9)
Zoning By-law
On February 22, 2023, City Council approved a motion directing staff to develop zoning provisions for renewable energy generation facilities (in accordance with Section 4.11 of the OP) in advance of the new Zoning By-law. The IESO LT2 RFP process is geared towards independent REGF projects that are not exempt from zoning under provincial legislation.
On July 12, 2023, Council approved amendments to the definition of Utility Installation in the Zoning By-law to exclude REGF. The amendment had the effect of recognizing REGF as independent from other types of Utility Installations. This change was made to conform with the policies within Official Plan Section 4.11. The new land use definitions are as follows:
Utility installation means the equipment used to make or deliver a utility product, commodity or service and includes the actual building, plant, works, utility line, tower, relay, pedestal, and may also include a storm water management facility, but excludes antenna systems and renewable energy generation facility
Renewable energy generation facility means a facility as defined in the Electricity Act, 1998, S.O. 1998, C. 15 Sched A, and not exempt under section 62(1) of the Planning Act, R.S.O, 1990, c. P.13.
Some renewable energy generation facilities, built in accordance with the Building Code, are exempt from zoning by-laws and therefore currently allowed. These include:
- roof or wall-mounted solar projects,
- roof or wall-mounted thermal air and thermal water projects and;
- ground-source heat pumps
(Source: O. Reg. 508/18: Designations Under Part II.3 of the Act)
Currently, renewable energy generation facilities that require provincial approval (e.g. wind and solar farms, bio-energy facilities of a certain size) are subject to a Zoning By-law Amendment application in order to be permitted. It is estimated that the next round of provincial procurement for such facilities will begin in the Fall of 2025, which is known as the LT2 procurement process. Staff continue to engage with the IESO as part of this process. At the same time, staff are currently exploring options to introduce provisions for accessory wind facilities.
Who's Listening
-
Email regf_iper@ottawa.ca -
Phone 6135802424 Email melissa.jort-conway@ottawa.ca
Follow Project
Key Dates
-
January 23 2025
-
February 05 2025
-
February 12 2025